Ammo for the #WarOnMen: Study Says Students Give Male Profs Better Evaluations
Providing more ammunition for the continuing campus “War on Men”, a new study claims that male professors are apt to get better evaluations than female counterparts.
Rumor had it the author of the study is Lena Dunham.
Students tend to give better evaluations to their professors if they think they’re male instead of female, according to a study published last week in the journal Innovative Higher Education.
The study, led by Lillian MacNell, a doctoral student at North Carolina State University, used an online summer course on introductory anthropology and sociology to, essentially, catfish students. The class was divided into four discussion groups, with two assistant instructors, one male and one female, teaching two discussions groups each. The assistant instructors collaborated to write and teach in similar ways.
However, the male instructor only told one of his groups that he was male, and told his other group he was female. Likewise, the female instructor only told one group she was female, and told her other group she was male.
At the end of the course, students were asked to fill out an evaluation about their instructor. Overall, the instructors did not receive significantly different evaluations. But the female instructor received better evaluations when students thought she was male. The male instructor, meanwhile, received worse evaluations when students thought he was female.
…The study argues that if these biases are coming across so clearly in teacher evaluations, “this particular form of inequality needs to be taken into consideration as women apply for academic jobs and come up for promotion and review.”
From the comments section:
[T]he actual female ratings were a rat’s hair higher than the actual male ratings, tho’ maybe not big enough to be statistically significant.
[R]eminds me of the whining about the math/science gap where high school boys do better than girls …. but when you look at language arts classes the gap is even bigger, and favors girls.
[W]e should worry that boys don’t develop language skills at least as much as girls avoiding science.
Students Give Professors Better Evaluations If They Think They're Male: Study (Huffington Post)