Victor Davis Hanson – Modern University Is Failing Students
In a new column for National Review, Victor Davis Hanson suggests that our higher education system is no longer achieving its objective. I couldn’t agree more.
The Modern University Is Failing Students in Every Respect
Modern American universities used to assume four goals.
First, their general education core taught students how to reason inductively and imparted an aesthetic sense through acquiring knowledge of Michelangelo, the Battle of Gettysburg, “Medea” and “King Lear,” Beethoven’s “Ode to Joy,” and astronomy and Euclidean geometry.
Second, campuses encouraged edgy speech and raucous expression — and exposure to all sorts of weird ideas and mostly unpopular thoughts. College talk was never envisioned as boring, politically correct megaphones echoing orthodox pieties.
Third, four years of college trained students for productive careers. Implicit was the university’s assurance that its degree was a wise career investment.
Finally, universities were not monopolistic price gougers. They sought affordability to allow access to a broad middle class that had neither federal subsidies nor lots of money. The American undergraduate university is now failing on all four counts.
A bachelor’s degree is no longer proof that any graduate can read critically or write effectively. National college-entrance-test scores have generally declined the last few years, and grading standards have as well.
Too often, universities emulate greenhouses where fragile adults are coddled as if they were hothouse orchids. Hypersensitive students are warned about “micro-aggressions” that in the real world would be imperceptible.
The Modern University Is Failing Students in Every Respect (National Review)
Comments
Well, VDH is right. I’ve returned to college, community college, to do a different type of program. The students and the universities reinforce each other. The students are close minded, unable to reason, lacking in critical thinking skills, intellectually incurious, unable to resolve disputes with each other without making reports to administration, incapable of QED writing. Yet, they are well indoctrinated. They want no ideas that challenge the ones they have received from wherever; they do not wish to hear anything that is not of their ideological persuasion. It’s horrifying, incredible, amazing, and sad.
My response has been to remain aloof. As a teacher, I have challenged my students to think. Always. I’m not their teacher, and I’m glad; these young people are snitches who yelp at the slightest perceived threat to their safe zones.
The university is failing them in not specifying to them the nature of the university, in hiring people who march in ideological lockstep, in not firing those who would demand ideological conformity and ridicule/condemn/belittle/degrade those with opposing ideas.
There is no challenge to the university anymore. I’m just marking time until the two years are up, and then farewell to the academy that I’ve long loved.