Student Accused of Hate Speech for Remarks in a Paper Will Sue School
A student at the University of New Mexico used phrases like “perverse attraction to the same sex” and “barren womb” when critiquing a lesbian film, and her teacher kicked her out of the class for hate speech. I can understand the reaction to “perverse”, but since when is “barren” hate speech?
Mike Bush at the Albuquerque Journal reports:
Lawsuit tests speech limits at UNM
A former student who was ostracized by her professors for making anti-gay remarks in a critique she wrote for a film class can proceed with her First Amendment lawsuit against the University of New Mexico.
Chief U.S. District Judge M. Christina Armijo denied UNM’s motion to dismiss the case, rejecting the argument that restrictions the university placed on the student were “reasonably related to legitimate pedagogic concerns.”
Monica Pompeo filed the suit last year, claiming UNM acted improperly when she was kicked out of the class for describing lesbianism as perverse in a critique of a lesbian romance film.
Pompeo enrolled in the course, “Images of (Wo)men: From Icons to Iconoclasts,” offered by professor Caroline Hinkley in the spring 2012 semester. As a class assignment, Pompeo critiqued a 1985 lesbian drama, “Desert Hearts.”
After Hinkley graded the critiques, she advised Pompeo to pick up her paper from the cinematic arts office and “ponder the responses” she had written on Pompeo’s paper.
Those responses included a comment that the critique was “inflammatory and offensive.” She also blasted Pompeo’s view that a lesbian character in the film had a “perverse attraction to the same sex” and a “barren womb.”
The lawsuit alleges Hinkley violated her own syllabus, which called for “open minds” to examine “representations of a plethora of genders and sexualities.” Instead, Pompeo says, Hinkley accused her of resorting to “hate speech” and refused to grade her paper. The professor also made it clear that it would be in Pompeo’s best interests not to return to the class, Pompeo alleges.
Later, Pompeo met with Hinkley’s supervisor, Susan Dever, chairwoman of the cinematic arts department. Pompeo was told that the use of “barren” was both inappropriate and offensive.
Comments
Two questions:
1. Is sex between two men or two women “normal”.
2. What is the definition of perverse? (Hint: See Wiki)
There is no difference in my opinion between the professor’s value judgment that criticism of homosexual relationships should not be tolerated and the student, whose value judgment equates homosexual activity with perversion. The difference is the professor has the power to punish the student thoughts and beliefs that do not coincide with the professor’s. In an academic environment, this inequality of power should not be tolerated.
As professor for over 40 years, I have never heard of anyone suggesting that a student leave a class because of difference of opinion on any topic. The school and the teacher (note I do not call her a professor) need to pay a heavy price for stupidity.