Study Says That Big Government Makes People More ‘Contented’
However, many countries with greater economic intervention by the government than the US — for example, France — are reportedly less content than Americans. So, is there really even a trend here?
The College Fix reports:
Study: Big Government Makes People ‘More Satisfied’
A study from Baylor University says that “People living in countries with governments that spend more on social services report being more contented.”
“The effect of state intervention into the economy equals or exceeds marriage or employment status — two traditional predictors of happiness — when it comes to satisfaction,” said Patrick Flavin, Ph.D., assistant professor of political science in Baylor’s College of Arts & Sciences.
Four measures of government policies were used by Flavin and co-researchers at the University of Notre Dame and Texas A&M University:
• The overall size of government consumption as a percentage of national gross domestic product.
• Social welfare expenditures as a percentage of the gross domestic product.
• Welfare state generosity measured in terms of the ease of access to welfare benefits, the expansiveness of coverage to citizens of different statuses and life circumstances, and the degree to which social benefits replace incomes lost due to unemployment, retirement, or family circumstances.
• Labor market regulations governing such circumstances as job dismissals, temporary employment, and mass layoffs.
The U.S. is located right in the middle of “satisfaction,” with countries like Belgium, France, and Germany reporting less contentment — countries with greater social spending (and arguably more of the other noted measures) than the U.S.
Which is a good thing, since Dr. Flavin is somewhat at odds with the very headline of the Baylor article: “Are we saying we need a bigger government to be happier? No. Instead, our goal is to objectively examine the data and let people draw their own conclusions.”
Comments
Big gov makes gov employees the happiest of all.
I take exception to the word “happiest”. I believe the correct word is “safest”. I believe that Americans have indeed evolved, but not in a positive fashion. I believe Americans have to a large extent, evolved into creatures who believe they cannot make it without a GOVERNment safety net. What makes people believe that is beyond my comprehension, but I believe that MANY Americans are ready to give up their freedoms in exchange for the fantasy that government cares about their well being. I believe the opposite is true, and I believe all conservatives hold that to be true.
Most Americans of today have never known anything but freedom, hence don’t appreciate it enough to protect it. I am saying they don’t recognize any loss of freedom and don’t understand freedoms here are lost incrementally – deliberately so that people do NOT grasp they are being subjugated to the state.
I believe the legal system could go a long way toward stopping the encroachment on individual lives, but simply chooses NOT to try to slow down the destruction of our civil liberties.
Contented.
A herd of cattle are contented.
That’s pretty much their vision.
Bravo… what came to mind was a flock of sheep, however bovine’s will do.