Would Banning Alcohol on Campus Reduce Sex Assaults at Dartmouth?
Joseph Asch examines the issue in a new post at Dartblog.
Shall We Just Ban Alcohol on Campus?
A thoughtful observer of the College scene has read this space’s reporting on sexual assault. His reaction has been voiced by other correspondents in the past:
Joe, You noted in the first paragraph: “Yes, alcohol is always part of the equation . . .” [of sexual assault]
It is illegal in the U.S. (and in New Hampshire specifically) to consume alcohol prior to age 21. If Dartmouth College and its students honor this very simple, concrete law of the land, what effect would that have in reducing the incidence of sexual assault and rape on campus?
This illustrates why “the age of majority” makes sense, and deserves to be respected and enforced: Until you are 21, don’t drink at Dartmouth. If consuming alcohol as a minor in our campus community and under our institutional responsibility is more important to you than following that one simple law, then please go to school elsewhere. As an Ivy League student, plenty of other places will take you.
What to say about this position, an eminently logical one? Alcohol does have myriad negative effects on life at Dartmouth, and if the penalty for consuming it were expulsion, drinking would probably end at the College. Shall we bring back Prohibition?
To start, we should note that only a severe penalty like the expulsion of students could work to rein in student drinking. In the past decade, Jim Wright’s administration rang up hundreds of students on College discipline for underage consumption, and now-retired Hanover Chief of Police Nick Giaccone’s force arrested many hundreds more. Keystone Cop scenes of officers chasing Keystone-consuming students through the bushes played out over and over again on campus. To no effect at all, of course, except to give students disciplinary or criminal records that impeded their efforts to be accepted at grad schools.
Comments
If college students want to be treated like children and not adults then so be it. Let’s given them the full monty: take away their driver’s license, make them eat at college dorms and nowhere else, restrict their access to what they can read and watch, etc.
If you want to be a child, then prepare to be treated like a child. Says something about these “educated elites” who can’t seem to handle alcohol without a mommy to tell them what to do, but who they consider their lessers (Those who enter the job market after high school) seem to do fine on average.
In a way – yes.
Right now someone can claim “oh, wait, I was drunk – therefore I could not consent”.
Removing alcohol WOULD reduce the number of people being molested while incapacitated, but also reduce the # of morning after regret accusations.